Struggling to keep your long hair up without causing damage or discomfort? You’re not alone—many people with long hair debate daily between claw clips and scrunchies for style, support, and ease.
People with long hair often prefer either claw clips or scrunchies depending on hair thickness, style preference, and comfort—both have unique benefits for managing long hair.
Let’s break down the pros and cons of each option and help you choose the best hair accessory based on your hair type and daily needs.
Claw Clips vs. Scrunchies: Which Is Better for Long Hair?
Tired of clips sliding or scrunchies pulling your hair too tightly? The right accessory makes all the difference.
Claw clips offer structured support and volume for thick long hair, while scrunchies provide flexible hold and gentle grip, making them ideal for comfort and low-tension styling.
How do the two compare in daily use?
Quick Comparison Table:
| Feature | Claw Clips | Scrunchies |
|---|---|---|
| Grip Strength | Strong, ideal for thick hair | Medium, better for casual styles |
| Hair Damage Risk | Low (if used correctly) | Very low due to soft material |
| Styling Versatility | Great for twists, updos | Best for ponytails, buns |
| Comfort | May press against head while leaning | Soft, good for sleeping |
| Aesthetic Appeal | Sleek, structured look | Soft, voluminous, trendy |
If you need your hair out of your face for work or errands, clips offer secure hold. For relaxed days, travel, or nighttime use, scrunchies shine.
When is one better than the other?
- Choose a claw clip for volume, elegant styling, and all-day hold
- Go with a scrunchie for comfort, no-crease ponytails, and low tension
Benefits of Using Claw Clips for Thick and Long Hairstyles
Do you find your hair falling out of regular hair ties after an hour?
Claw clips are a go-to solution for long, thick hair because they distribute weight evenly, hold secure without pulling, and allow stylish, mess-free updos.
What makes claw clips effective for long hair?
- Large teeth grip thick sections of hair
- Even tension prevents stress on roots
- Easy to reposition without breakage
- No tangling like elastic bands can cause
Claw clips are especially effective for styles like:
- French twists
- Half-up half-down lifts
- Low buns with volume
- Quick claw-clip flips (the “model off-duty” look)
What type of clip works best?
Recommended Claw Clip Features for Long Hair:
| Feature | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Oversized Body | Covers more hair, stronger grip |
| Interlocking Teeth | Prevents slipping throughout the day |
| Reinforced Spring | Ensures lasting hold |
| Curved Shape | Cradles the shape of your head comfortably |
At AceAccessory, for example, our oversized acetate clips are designed to handle heavy, thick hair with durable grip and soft edges.
Why Scrunchies Remain a Favorite for Long Hair Comfort
Wish your hair tie wouldn’t leave creases or cause breakage after hours of wear?
Scrunchies are beloved for long hair because they hold securely without tugging, reduce tension, and come in soft fabrics that prevent creases and split ends.
What makes scrunchies a go-to for long-haired users?
- Gentle grip that won’t pull or damage strands
- Lightweight and easy to carry on the go
- No ridges or creases in hair after removal
- Stylish & soft for any age or hair type
They're perfect for:
- Low ponytails
- Loose messy buns
- Sleep styles
- Gym sessions
Which scrunchie material is best?
Ideal Scrunchie Fabrics:
| Fabric Type | Benefits for Long Hair |
|---|---|
| Silk/Satin | Glide easily, reduce friction |
| Cotton | Everyday wear, breathable |
| Velvet | Added grip for thick hair |
| Jersey Knit | Stretchy, casual, great for buns |
Using satin scrunchies at night helps protect ends and reduce frizz—perfect for maintaining long hairstyles with minimal heat.
How to Choose the Right Hair Accessory Based on Hair Type and Style?
Confused by the options and unsure which to grab each morning?
Choose between claw clips and scrunchies based on your hair’s thickness, the look you want, and the activity planned—comfort and security are key.
How does hair type influence your choice?
Quick Guide Based on Hair Texture & Needs:
| Hair Type | Best Accessory | Why It Works |
|---|---|---|
| Long + Thick | Large Claw Clip | Holds weight, adds volume |
| Long + Fine | Soft Scrunchie | Gentle grip, avoids tension |
| Curly/Wavy | Wide Tooth Clip | Preserves curl pattern, no breakage |
| Straight | Either (depends on style) | Clips for updos, scrunchies for ponytails |
You might even mix both—use a scrunchie at night and a claw clip during the day for a complete, hair-safe routine.
What else should you consider?
- For work: Choose a sleek, neutral claw clip
- For casual or home use: Soft cotton or satin scrunchies
- For travel: Use clip to refresh hair without a brush
- For exercise: Fabric scrunchies or no-slip sports clips
Conclusion
Whether you love the structure of a claw clip or the softness of a scrunchie, the best choice depends on your hair’s length, thickness, and how you plan to style it. Many with long hair use both depending on the day—clips for sleek updos and scrunchies for gentle comfort.
